Instructions
-
Season the chicken
Rub generously with salt and pepper, including inside the cavity. -
Cook in slow cooker
Place chicken in slow cooker, add enough water to cover, and cook:-
Low: 8–10 hours
-
High: 5 hours
-
-
Remove and shred
Carefully lift chicken out (it should fall apart). Remove skin and bones, shred meat. -
Strain broth
Strain cooking liquid into a large pot — this becomes your rich broth. -
Combine and season
Add shredded chicken back to broth. Bring to a boil, stir in 4 tbsp chicken base, taste, and adjust seasoning. -
Cook noodles
Add noodles directly to the boiling broth and cook 8–10 minutes, until tender. -
Finish
Stir in butter if using. The dish will look soupy at first — that’s correct! Noodles soak up broth as it rests. -
Serve
Ladle over mashed potatoes for a classic Amish-style meal, or serve in bowls with crusty bread.
Notes & Tips
-
Straining the broth gives a cleaner, richer dish.
-
Start with less chicken base — you can always add more.
-
Texture should be slightly soupy; it thickens as noodles absorb liquid.
-
Save extra broth for soups or gravies.
-
Freezes well if you add fresh noodles after thawing.
Nutrition (per serving, ~8 servings)
-
Calories: 454
-
Protein: 27g
-
Carbs: 31g
-
Fat: 24g
No Responses Yet